含高比例户用光伏的低压配电网电压控制研究综述

4.3 交直流混合配电网的电压控制研究

相比于低压交流配电网,低压直流配电网具有线路损耗小、节约成本等特点,且户用光伏及储能也更易于接入,同时具有更好的供电可靠性和电能质量[68],一些文献对于直流配电网的拓扑结构,规划以及控制问题进行了相关的讨论[69-71]。但是,将当前的交流网络直接转换成直流网络尚存在巨大的政策、资金以及技术挑战,因此,低压交流配网向低压交直流混合配网过渡成为当前网络发展的趋势之一,并且有可能在未来长期保持下去。文献[72]提出一种基于交直流互联的低压配网转供模型,如图8所示,利用AC/DC换流器将不同负荷特性的馈线末端连接起来,并且通过变下垂系数策略调节换流器流过功率的大小和方向,使得负荷特性不同的馈线功率均衡,可以有效化解电压风险。

文献[73]则提出了交直流线路并行架设的网络结构,如图9所示,交直流接口同时入户,传统交流网络的并网负荷、控制设备和控制方式不变,户用光伏以及电动汽车则通过直流馈线并网;直流馈线通过首端的储能控制,还可以稳定首端交流母线的电压,极大的降低了网络运行风险和设备投资。

图8 基于交直流混合低压配电网转供模型

图9 交直流线路并行架设结构

4.4 多目标多场景的电压控制研究

当前多数控制方法的控制目标和场景比较单一。一方面,这些文献重点解决光伏并网后所引起的电压越上限问题,对于传统的夜间重负荷所引起的欠电压问题以及光伏功率波动所引起的网络电压波动问题考虑还有所欠缺,即控制并没有充分考虑光伏的运行场景。另一方面,也鲜有文献考虑控制策略对于网络损耗和网络功率因数的影响,即控制并没有充分考虑网络运行指标。因此,有必要在含有高比例户用光伏发电的低压配电网中建立多场景、多目标的控制模型,兼顾网络风险的抑制及网络运行指标的优化。

4.5 考虑经济性因素的电压控制研究

当前,政策性因素是推进户用光伏并网的主要动力,但最终将会被市场和价格因素所取代。在此背景下户用光伏消纳问题的利益主体将变得多元化,基于一定的价格要素考虑光伏的并网以及网络电压控制等问题会更加合理,如可以建立不同利益主体间光伏并网和辅助服务的博弈及合作模型。在此背景下低压配网的电压控制将被赋予经济和价格属性,相关的研究将会对光伏的并网和设备的高效利用起到促进作用,也会对并网政策的完善提供参考和依据。

4.6 光储虚拟同步机建模及电压控制研究

与经过逆变器并网的电源不同,同步发电机的并网功率具有很大的惯性,避免了并网功率的快速波动。通过对光储逆变器的参数设置以及阻抗匹配,可以使分布式光储系统具有与同步发电机类似的并网特性[74-76]。当前文献对光储虚拟同步机建模的研究还有所不足,多采用简化的网络模型并且没有充分考虑低压网络的参数特点,光储虚拟同步机对网络电压的影响及调节作用的研究也较少。因此,相关的研究还有待补充和完善。

4.7 新型电力电子设备的研制

一些新型电力电子设备在低压配电网中的应用正在受到关注。固态分接头变压器的分接头变化不再需要进行机械性的调整,图10是固态分接头的结构示意图,通过对晶闸管的开合操作即可调整变压器的变比,避免了分接头的磨损,使得变压器的变比可以频繁调节[51],这将极大增强网络的电压调节能力。类似设备在低压配网中的应用还有待补充和完善。

图10 含固态分接头变压器的控制原理图

5 结语

本文围绕含高比例户用光伏低压配电网电压控制问题,总结了户用光伏在低压配电网的并网特征及其引起的电压问题,基于电压灵敏度理论介绍了当前低压配电网的电压控制原理。并以此为基础,结合低压配电网的通信条件,综述了基于有功、无功以及分接头的电压控制方法,同时对多类设备的协调控制方法也进行了介绍,总结了不同控制方法的使用场景、优势与不足之处。最后,对解决低压配电网电压问题的新技术进行了展望,以期能为该领域将来的研究提供一些参考。

参考文献

[1] 刘健,黄炜.分布式光伏电源与负荷分布接近条件下的可接入容量分析[J].电网技术,2015,39(2):299-306. Liu Jian,Huang Wei.Analysis on grid-connectible capacity of distributed PV generation in case of PV generation distribution close to load distribution[J].Power System Technology,2015,39(2):299-306(in Chinese).

[2] 郑超,林俊杰,赵健,等.规模化光伏并网系统暂态功率特性及电压控制[J].中国电机工程学报,2015,35(5):1059-1071. Zheng Chao,Lin Junjie,Zhao Jian,et al.Transient power acteristic of scaled photovoltaic grid-connected system and its voltage control[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2015,35(5):1059-1071(in Chinese).

[3] 左伟杰,马钊,周莉梅,等.基于配电网电能质量健康评估策略的分布式光伏接入方法[J].电网技术,2015,39(12):3442-3448. Zuo Weijie,Ma Zhao,Zhou Limei,et al.Grid-connection of distributed photovoltaic generation method based on the power quality health status of distribution system[J].Power System Technology,2015,39(12):3442-3448(in Chinese).

[4] 马丽,刘念,张建华,等.自动需求响应模式下光伏用户群的优化运行模型[J].中国电机工程学报,2016,36(13):3422-3432. Ma Li,Liu Nian,Zhang Jianhua,et al.Optimal operation model of user group with photovoltaic in the mode of automatic demand response[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2016,36(13):3422-3432(in Chinese).

[5] 赵晋泉,刘绪,林昌年,等.单相光伏大量接入的三相不平衡配电网无功优化[J].电力系统自动化,2016,40(13):13-18. Zhao Jinquan,Liu Xu,Lin Changnian,et al.Three-phase unbalanced reactive power optimization for distribution systems with a large numberof single phase solar generators[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2016,40(13):13-18(in Chinese).

[6] Mejbaul H M,Peter W.A review of high PV penetrations in LV distribution networks: present status, impacts and mitigation measures[J].Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2016(62):1195-1208.

[7] Li Q,Wolfs P.A review of the single phase photovoltaic module integrated converter topologies with three different DC link configurations[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,2008,23(3):1320-1333.

[8] Nasif M,Zahedi A.Review of control strategies for voltage regulation of the smart distribution network with high penetration of renewable distributed generation[J].Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2016(64):582-595.

[9] Benoit B,Serdar K,Roman B,et al.Voltage control with PV inverters in low voltage networks-in depth analysis of different concepts and parameterization criteria[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2017,32(1):177-185.

[10] Afshin S,Robert E,Lennart S,et al.Coordinated active power-dependent voltage regulation in distribution grids with PV systems[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery,2014,29(3):1454-1464.

[11] Karl W,Kellett C M,Philipp B,et al.Distributed and decentralized control of residential energy systems incorporating battery storage[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2015,6(4):1914-1923.

[12] Alam M J E,Muttaqi K M, Sutanto D.A multi-mode control strategy for var support by solar PV inverters in distribution networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2015,30(3):1316-1326.

[13] Sam W,Johan D.Optimal local reactive power control by PV inverters[J].IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,2016,7(4):1624-1633.

[14] 许晓艳,黄越辉,刘纯,等.分布式光伏发电对配电网电压的影响及电压越限的解决方案[J].电网技术,2010,34(10):140-146. Xu Xiaoyan,Huang Yuehui,Liu Chun,et al.The solution of distributed PV generation on distribution network voltage and voltage limit[J].Power System Technology,2010,34(10):140-146(in Chinese).

[15] 王颖,文福拴,赵波,等.高密度分布式光伏接入下电压越限问题的分析与对策[J].中国电机工程学报,2016,36(5):1200-1206. Wang Ying,Wen Fushuan,Zhao Bo,et al.Analysis and ermeasures of voltage violation problems caused by high-density distributed photovoltaics[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2016,36(5):1200-1206(in Chinese).

[16] Ahmed E-N,Istvàn E.Control approach of three-phase grid connected PV inverters for voltage unbalance mitigation in low-voltage distribution grids[J].IET Renewable Power Generation,2016,10(10):1577-1586.

[17] 刘科研,何开元,盛万兴.基于协同粒子群优化算法的配电网三相不平衡状态估计[J].电网技术,2014,38(4):1026-1031. Liu Keyan,He Kaiyuan,Sheng Wanxing.A cooperative particle swarm optimization based state estimation of unbalanced three-phase distribution network[J].Power System Technology,2014,38(4):1026-1031(in Chinese).

[18] Fekete K,Klaic Z,Majdandzic L.Expansion of the residential photovoltaic systems and its harmonic impact on the distribution grid[J].Renewable Energy,2012(43):140-148.

[19] 温阳东,王欣.分布式发电对配电网继电保护的影响[J].继电器,2008,36(1):12-14. WenYangdong,Wang Xin.Effect of distributed generation on protection in distribution system[J].Relay,2008,36(1):12-14(in Chinese).

[20] Procopiou A T,Ochoa L F.Voltage control in PV-rich LV networks without remote monitoring[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2017,32(2):1224-1236.

[21] Long C,O L F.Voltage control of PV-rich LV networks: OLTC-fitted transformer and capacitor banks[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2016,31(5):4016-4025.

[22] Reinaldo T,Lopes L A C,El-Fouly T H M.Coordinated active power curtailment of grid connected PV inverters for overvoltage prevention[J].IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,2011,2(2):139-147.

[23] 张璐,唐巍,丛鹏伟,等.含光伏发电的配电网有功无功资源综合优化配置[J].中国电机工程学报,2014,34(31):5525-5533. Zhang Lu,Tang Wei,Cong Pengwei,et al.Optimal configuration of active-reactive power sources in distribution network with photovoltaic generation[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2014,34(31):5525-5533(in Chinese).

[24] Morris B,Ettore D B,Luca D C,et al.Automatic distributed voltage control algorithm in smart grids applications[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2013,4(2):877-885.

[25] Alam M J E,Muttaqi K M,Sutanto D.A SAX-based advanced computational tool for assessment of clustered rooftop solar PV impacts on LV and MV networks in smart grid[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2013,4(1):577-585.

[26] 李清然,张建成.含分布式光伏电源的配电网电压越限解决方案[J].电力系统自动化,2015,39(22):117-123. Li Qingran,Zhang Jiancheng.Solutions of voltage beyond limits in distribution network with distributed photovoltaic generators[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2015,39(22):117-123(in Chinese).

[27] Abdullah B,Ashhar R,Marc D-A,et al.Combined effect of CVR and DG penetration in the voltage profile of low-voltage secondary distribution networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery,2016,31(1):286-293.

[28] Izudin D,Jabr R A,Ema H,et al.A sensitivity approach to model local voltage controllers in distribution networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2014,29(3):1419-1428.

[29] Alberto B,Mauro B,Samuele G,et al.Short-term scheduling and control of active distribution systems with high penetration of renewable resources[J].IEEE Systems Journal,2010,4(3):313-322.

[30] Efkarpidis N,De Rybel T,Driesen J.Technical assessment of centralized and localized voltage control strategies in low voltage networks[J].Sustainable Energy, Grids and Networks,2016(8):85-97.

[31] Morris B,Ettore D B,Luca D C,et al.Automatic distributed voltage control algorithm in smart grids applications[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2013,4(2):877-885.

[32] 蔡永翔,张璐,唐巍,等.考虑逆变器无功充裕性的含高比例户用光伏低压配电网电压控制策略[J].电网技术,2017,41(9):2799-2807. Cai Yongxiang,Zhang Lu,Tang Wei,et al.A voltage control strategy for LV distribution network with high proportion residential PVs considering reactive power adequacy of PV inverters[J].Power System Technology,2017,41(9):2799-2807(in Chinese).

[33] Thomas S,Frank M,Martin B.Improved low voltage grid-integration of photovoltaic systems in Germany[J].IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,2013,4(2):534-542.

[34] Tonkoski R,Lopes L A C.Impact of active power curtailment on overvoltage prevention and energy production of PV inverters connected to low voltage residential feeders[J].Renewable Energy,2011,36(12):3566-3574.

[35] Farag H E Z,El-Saadany E F.A novel cooperative protocol for distributed voltage control in active distribution systems[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2013:1645-1656.

[36] Wang Y,Tan K T,Peng X Y,et al.Coordinated control of distributed energy-storage systems for voltage regulation in distribution networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery,2016,31(3):1132-1141.

[37] Keigo S,Akiko T,Imai Jun,et al.A novel voltage control method in low-voltage distribution systems:cooperative autonomous switching control[C]//Industrial Electronics Society,IECON 2015- Conference of the IEEE.Yokohama,Japan:IEEE,2015:583-588.

[38] Wai K Y,Havas L,Overend E,et al.Neural network-based active power curtailment for overvoltage prevention in low voltage feeders[J].Expert Systems with Applications,2014,41(4):1063-1070.

[39] Tonkoski R,Lopes L.Voltage regulation in radial distribution feeders with high penetration of photovoltaic[C]//Energy 2030 Conference,2008.Atlanta,USA:IEEE,2008:1-7.

[40] Wang P,Liang D H,Yi J,et al.Integrating electrical energy storage into coordinated voltage control schemes for distribution networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2014,5(2):1018-1032.

[41] Gill S,Kockar I,Ault G W.Dynamic optimal power flow for active distribution networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2014,29(1):121-131.

[42] Wong J,Lim Y S,Morris E.Novel fuzzy controlled energy storage for low-voltage distribution networks with photovoltaic systems under highly cloudy conditions[J].Journal of Energy Engineering,2015,141(1):B4014001.

[43] Alam M,Muttaqi K,Sutanto D.A novel approach for ramp-rate control of solar PV using energy storage to mitigate output fluctuations caused by cloud passing[J].IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion,2014,29(2):507-518.

[44] Chua K H,Yun S L,Taylor P,et al.Energy storage system for mitigating voltage unbalance on low-voltage networks with photovoltaic systems[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery,2012,27(4):1783-1790.

[45] Kein H C,Yun S L,Jianhui W,et al.Voltage unbalance mitigation in low voltage distribution networks with photovoltaic systems[J].Journal of Electronic Science and Technology,2012,10(1):1-6.

[46] Wang Y,Wang B F,Ping L S.A voltage regulation method using distributed energy storage systems in LV distribution networks [C]//IEEE International Energy Conference.Leuven,Belgium:IEEE, 2016:1-6.

[47] Worthmann K,Kellett C M,Braun P,et al.Distributed and decentralized control of residential energy systems incorporating battery storage[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2015,6(4):1914-1923.

[48] Wang L,Liang D H,Crossland A F,et al.Coordination of multiple energy storage units in a low-voltage distribution network[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2015,6(6):2906-2918.

[49] Olek B,Wierzbowski M.Local energy balancing and ancillary services in low-voltage networks with distributed generation, energy storage, and active loads[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,2015,62(4):2499-2508.

[50] Sugihara H,Yokoyama K,Saeki O,et al.Economic and efficient voltage management using customer-owned energy storage systems in a distribution network with high penetration of photovoltaic systems[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2013,28(1):102-111.

[51] Kabiri R,Holmes D G,McGrath B P,et al.LV grid voltage regulation using transformer electronic tap changing,with PV inverter reactive power injection[J].IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics,2015,3(4):1182-1192.

[52] CENELEC.EN 50160 Voltage acteristics of electricity supplied by public distribution networks[S].Brussels,2010.

[53] 中华人民共和国国家质量监督检验检疫总局,中国国家标准化管理委员会.GB\T 19964—2012光伏电站接入电力系统技术规定[S].北京:中国标准出版社,2012.

[54] Demirok E,González P C,Frederiksen K H B,et al.Local reactive power control methods for overvoltage prevention of distributed solar inverters in low-voltage grids[J].IEEE Journal of Photovoltaics,2011,1(2):174-182.

[55] Pham H V,Rueda J L,Erlich I.Probabilistic evaluation of voltage and reactive power control methods of wind generators in distribution networks[J].IET Renewable Power Generation,2014,9(3):195-206.

[56] Mokhtari G,Ghosh A,Nourbakhsh G,et al.Smart robust resources control in LV network to deal with voltage rise issue[J].IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,2013,4(4):1043-1050.

[57] Vasquez J C,Mastromauro R A,Guerrero J M,et al.Voltage support provided by a droop-controlled multifunctional inverter[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,2009,56(11):4510-4519.

[58] Jahangiri P,Aliprantis D C.Distributed volt/var control by PV inverters[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2013,28(3):3429-3439.

[59] Samadi A,Shayesteh E,Eriksson R,et al.Multi-objective coordinated droop-based voltage regulation in distribution grids with PV systems[J].Renewable Energy,2014(71):315-323.

[60] Bletterie B.Local voltage control by PV inverters:first operating experience from simulation,laboratory tests and field tests[C]// European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition.Paris,France,2013:4210-4216.

[61] Wang H,Stetz T,Kraiczy M,et al.Parallel operation of photovoltaic inverters with autonomous voltage control strategies comparison of Q(V)/P(V) and automatic voltage limitation[C]//European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference EUPVSEC.Amsterdam,The Netherlands:EUPVSEC,2014:2921-2926.

[62] Long C,Procopiou A T,Ochoa L F,et al.Performance of OLTC-based control strategies for LV networks with photovoltaics [C]//2015 IEEE Power & Energy Society General Meeting.Denver,USA:IEEE,2015:1-5.

[63] Long C,Ochoa L F.Voltage Control of PV-Rich LV Networks:OLTC-Fitted Transformer and Capacitor Banks[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2016,31(5):4016-4025.

[64] Muttaqi K M,Le A D T,Negnevitsky M,et al.A coordinated voltage control approach for coordination of OLTC, voltage regulator, and DG to regulate voltage in a distribution feeder[J].IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications,2015,51(2):1239-1248.

[65] Liu X,Aichhorn A,Liu L,et al.Coordinated control of distributed energy storage system with tap changer transformers for voltage rise mitigation under high photovoltaic penetration[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2012,3(2):897-906.

[66] Kabir M N,Mishra Y,Ledwich G,et al.Coordinated control of grid-connected photovoltaic reactive power and battery energy storage systems to improve the voltage profile of a residential distribution feeder[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics,2014,10(2):967-977.

[67] 吴聪,唐巍,白牧可,等.基于能源路由器的用户侧能源互联网规划[J].电力系统自动化,2017,41(4):20-28. Wu Cong,Tang Wei,Bai Muke,et al.Energy router based planning of energy internet at user side[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2017,41(4):20-28(in Chinese).

[68] 宋强,赵彪,刘文华,等.智能直流配电网研究综述[J].中国电机工程学报,2013,33(25):9-19. SongQiang,Zhao Biao,Liu Wenhua,et al.An overview of research on smart DC distribution power network[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2013,33(25):9-19(in Chinese).

[69] Bokyung K,Utomo N P,Jang G,et al.Optimal scheduling for the complementary energy storage system operation based on smart metering data in the DC distribution system[J].Energies,2013,6(12):6569-6585.

[70] Hakala T,Lahdeaho T,Jarventausta P.Low-voltage DC distribution- utilization potential in a large distribution network company[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery,2015,30(4):1694-1701.

[71] Hamad A A,Farag H E,El-Saadany E F.A novel multiagent control scheme for voltage regulation in DC distribution systems[J].IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,2015,6(2):534-545.

[72] Pei W,Deng W,Zhang X,et al.Potential of using multiterminal LVDC to improve plug-in electric vehicle integration in an existing distribution network[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,2015,62(5):3101-3111.

[73] ElNozahy M S,Salama M M A.uncertainty-based design of a bilayer distribution system for improved integration of PHEVs and PV arrays[J].IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,2015,6(3):659-674.

[74] Alatrash H,Mensah A,Mark E,et al.Generator emulation controls for photovoltaic inverters[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2012,3(2):996-1011.

[75] 温烨婷,戴瑜兴,毕大强,等.一种电网友好型光储分布式电源控制策略[J].中国电机工程学报,2017,37(2):464-476. Wen Yeting,Dai Yuxing,Bi Daqiang,et al.A grid friendly PV/BESS distributed generation control strategy[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2017,37(2):464-476(in Chinese).

[76] 郑天文,陈来军,刘炜,等.考虑源端动态特性的光伏虚拟同步机多模式运行控制[J].中国电机工程学报,2017,37(2):454-464. Zheng Tianwen,Chen Laijun,Liu Wei,et al.Multi-mode operation control for photovoltaic virtual synonous generator considering the dynamic acteristics of primary source[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2017,37(2):454-464(in Chinese).